There is a minor tempest in Leesburg over the 100th anniversary of the Confederate Memorial Statue on the courthouse lawn. The United Daughters of the Confederacy had requested $3,300 from the County for a celebration of the statue. When the request was presented to the Board, our Supervisors forwarded it on to the appropriate subcommittee for consideration.
PRESENTATION BY THE UNITED DAUGHTERS OF THE CONFEDERACY:
Becky Hackney Fleming of the United Daughters of the Confederacy made a presentation on the Loudoun’s Silent Sentinel - Celebrating 100 Years. She asked that the Board of Supervisors consider funding $3300 for the 100th Anniversary Celebration to help with the cost of the event to be held in the Town of Leesburg on Saturday, May 31, 2008 at 1:00 p.m.
Supervisor Buckley moved that the Board of Supervisors forward the request of the United Daughters of the Confederacy for a contribution of $3300 for the 100th Anniversary celebration to the Finance/Government Services and Operations Committee on May 7, 2008. The motion passed 7-0-2, Supervisor Kurtz and York absent for the vote. - Board Meeting Minutes

The United Daughters of the Confederacy (Full disclosure: My grandmother was a member of the UDC. -P13) has
withdrawn their request in response to a few questions about it from two of our Supervisors.
In a May 1 letter to county supervisors, the group says that negative comments by board members have led to an outpouring of donations from residents. Supervisors Stevens Miller (D-Dulles) and Kelly Burk (D-Leesburg) both made comments about the statue after the UDC's request for funding.
Miller said that a confederate soldier pointing a gun at him isn't necessarily the first thing he wants to see when walking up to the courthouse. Burk wondered why there couldn't be a celebration to laud veterans from both sides of the Civil War, not just the Confederacy.
"How unreasonable of me?" Burk said sarcastically. The supervisor said she felt like the UDC exaggerated the comments made by her and Miller to raise money. - Leesburg Today
It is interesting that a
staunchly conservative group such as the
United Daughters of the Confederacy would be seeking public funds for their cultural celebration so soon after the
bruising budget battles the Board just completed. With the wailing and gnashing of teeth over public spending from conservative circles, how is it that one of their most revered organizations sees no problem seeking tax dollars for their event? Where is the seething over possible spending on arts and culture so typical of some Supervisors?
Furthermore, it why did the United Daughters of the Confederacy request the funding, only to withdraw the request when two of nine Supervisors raised some questions, but before the request had been considered by the subcommittee or the Board as a whole. Supervisors Burk and Miller did not
oppose the funding request, they merely had some questions. Questions from two of nine Supervisors does not provide any indication that the Board was going to deny the request. On the contrary, it would seem to indicate a likely approval to have only two Supervisors asking questions.
In the interests of accuracy, here is what Supervisor Burk actually had to say on the matter:
"Outside the board room, Supervisor Kelly Burk (D-Leesburg) said equal billing for both sides of the war might go a long way toward convincing the board to hand over the money.
“Isn't there a Union location that could also be heralded,” she said. “Let's celebrate all veterans.” - Supervisor Kelly Burk
As a result of the abrupt withdrawl of the request, a great opportunity to honor all veterans has been lost. Along with the Confederate Memorial, Leesburg is home to a
national cemetery at Balls Bluff, where 54 Union veterans are interred. Indeed, it would be a worthy demonstration of Loudoun's past, present and future to honor together our Confederate and Union dead in the same event, as descendants of both sides have come and settled in Loudoun, living peaceably together for nearly 150 years. The dates are even compatible, as May 30th is the
day designated to honor Union war dead by the Sons of the Union Veterans of the Civil War. (That's where the idea of "
Memorial Day" comes from, after all.)
If it was truly the purpose of the United Daughters of the Confederacy to get public funding for their celebration there was clearly no reason to withdraw their request. Only two Supervisors had questions about it, and one of the two - Supervisor Burk - clearly indicated that she would support the request were it to accommodate honoring Union veterans as well, a perfectly reasonable request in a County whose population so largely descends today from immigrants north of the Potomac.
The withdrawl of the funding request seems to indicate that the United Daughters of the Confederacy is more interested in a fundraising "issue" than actually honoring our civil war dead. This "issue" seems to be a minor skirmish in the ever-fought culture war about "heritage" which so tires and exasperates the hard working people of Loudoun who want to prepare for tomorrow's battles, not refight yesterday's.
Loudoun, and Virginia, do indeed have
a proud history and heritage, but it is a history and heritage made by both sides of the civil war, and one which can be questioned without being demeaned. To take offense to simple questions and withdraw this funding request is to demonstrate that the appearance of a slight is far more important than the honoring of our history. It is to the credit of Supervisors Burk and Miller that they were willing to ask questions, because unquestioned homage to history is the path of self-delusion and disappointment. And that is a path that Loudoun will always to well to avoid.